Aging Skin: Blemishes and Nonmelanoma Skin Cancers

Description

Alternative Names

Treatment

Although any diagnosis of cancer is frightening, very few people die of nonmelanoma skin cancers. They are generally slow growing and very curable. A number of options are available for treating these skin problems, including surgery, cryosurgery, phototherapy, radiation, and topical 5-fluorouracil. Few comparison studies have been performed to see which procedures are most effective for these skin problems.

Surgery

For any skin cancer and for some keratoses that require removal, surgery is the first treatment. It is usually one of the following:

Excisional Surgery. This is simply surgical removal of the cancerous lesion.

Curettage and Electrodessication. This procedure involves scraping away of the cancerous tissue followed by electric cauterization to stop the bleeding.

Mohs Micrographic Surgery. Mohs surgery is a meticulous procedure used for skin cancers at high risk for recurrence or becoming invasive. Studies indicate patients with the following skin cancers are among the good candidates for this procedure:

• Squamous cell carcinomas.
• Basal cell carcinomas greater than 1 cm (about half an inch).
• Basal cell carcinomas on the face, ear, or neck.
• Skin cancer that occurs in young people.

This procedure involves the following:

• Very thin layers are removed one at time, with each layer examined immediately under a microscope.
• When the layers are shown to be cancer free, the surgery is complete.
• Because the physician needs to be certain that all cancer cells are removed, in some cases the surgical area required is very wide and requires plastic surgical techniques. Human skin substitute (Apligraf) is a living biological dressing that is being investigated. It is applied to the surgical area to achieve a better cosmetic effect.

Mohs surgery saves more healthy tissue than other procedures and is highly effective. It results in a 99% cure rate for primary tumors and a 95% cure rate for recurrent ones. It can be safely performed in the doctor's office. Complications are uncommon but can include bleeding and infection.

Lasers. Laser surgery may be useful for certain basal cells and for keratoses that appear on the lips, although it is not clear whether lasers offer any advantages over other surgical treatments. Lasers do not appear to be very effective for thick or tough squamous cell carcinomas.

Cryosurgery

Cryosurgery removes skin cancer cells or actinic keratoses by freezing the affected tissue with liquid nitrogen (a technique known as cryosurgery). Studies report the following:

• It can remove even wide areas of actinic keratoses and may be more effective over the long term than treatment with 5-fluorouracil, the standard drug. Cryosurgery also appears to reduce the risk for squamous cell carcinoma in these patients.
• A head-to-head comparison or a freezing technique with Mohs micrographic surgery in patients with basal cell carcinomas (BCCs) reported similar recurrence rates with each approach. Over 85% of the patients with the freezing technique were satisfied with the appearance of the area afterwards. Five-year recurrence rates were only 2.1%. (Mohs surgery is still the treatment of choice for high-risk BCCs.)

Cryotherapy achieves good cosmetic results for many patients. However, it may cause blistering and ulceration, leading to pain and infection, as well as harmless, but undesirable, skin-color changes.

Radiation

In unusual cases where the carcinoma may be in an inoperable position (such as the eyelid or the tip of the nose) or if cancer has recurred multiple times, radiation therapy may be indicated. Radiation is directed at the tumor. It may take one to four weeks with treatments performed several times a week. One technique being investigated for basal and squamous cell carcinoma uses radiation implants (brachytherapy) and custom-made molds to specifically target the radiation. Studies suggest that this treatment is very effective with few complications.

Topical Phototherapy and Aminolevulinic Acid (ALA)

Topical phototherapy with aminolevulinic acid (ALA) is a nonsurgical method that is proving to be a good choice for treating actinic keratoses and some nonmelanoma skin cancers (Bowen's disease and basal cell carcinoma). It employs blue light administered after that patient has taken aminolevulinic acid (Levulan, Karastik). ALA accumulates in the skin cells and when exposed to intense light, the chemical causes these cells to die. This approach allows precise targeting of one or more lesions, leaving healthy skin unaffected.

It does not penetrate deeper than the epidermis (the top layer of the skin), so it does not produce scarring or changes in skin color, as cryotherapy or other more invasive treatments do.

It can cause pain, irritation, including stinging, itching, and burning, but in one study only 3% of patients stopped using it for this reason. In a 2002 study, the procedure was more painful for patients with actinic keratoses than for those with nonmelanoma skin cancers. It was also painful when large areas were affected, and men experienced more pain than women.

ALA Phototherapy for Actinic Keratoses. Phototherapy is showing very good results for actinic keratoses. It works best on flat lesions performed in two treatments, and is more effective for clearing lesions on the face than those on the scalp. Phototherapy can also treat multiple lesions at the same time instead of sequentially, as in cryotherapy. Studies to date suggest that it may be as effective as cryotherapy and achieve better cosmetic results. (More patients report burning and itching with phototherapy, however.) Phototherapy is also equal to topical 5-fluorouracil in effectiveness and achieving a satisfactory appearance.

ALA Phototherapy for Nonmelanoma Skin Cancers. In patients with squamous cell carcinoma-in-situ (Bowen's disease) and basal cell carcinoma, phototherapy has been equal to cryotherapy, with superior healing and appearance afterward. A 2003 study reported that it was more effective than topical 5-FU for patients with Bowen's disease and there were fewer side effects.

Nevertheless, two 2001 studies reported that despite initial good results, about 10% of patients using phototherapy experienced a recurrence within one year. These recurrence rates are higher than with surgery and other standard treatments. Longer-term studies are required before ALA phototherapy can be recommended for most patients with nonmelanoma skin cancers.

Exfoliation

Chemical peeling, or exfoliation, is useful for solar keratoses on the face, especially in people with fair, dry skin. Alpha-hydroxy acids, for example, are being investigated for keratoses. Dermabrasion, which "sands" the skin, may also be effective although scarring is possible. A 2002 study found laser resurfacing to treat severe sun damage on the face; however, it may not prevent nonmelanoma skin cancers.

Medications

A number of medications are being used for keratoses and some may be helpful for skin cancers as well. Besides cryotherapy, 5-fluorouracil is the other most commonly used treatment for actinic keratoses. Other medications are also available.